City expresses intent to improve emergency medical response

On November 14, 2018, in Latest News, by The Somerville Times

The Somerville Board of Aldermen issued an Aldermanic Communication at their latest regular meeting last week resolving to improve emergency medical response systems in the city.

By Jim Clark

Following the tragic loss of Laura Levis, who died after suffering an asthma attack while unsuccessfully seeking emergency care at Somerville Hospital in September, the City of Somerville Board of Aldermen officially expressed its intent to work towards helping improve systems involving emergency response, care and education related to asthma.

The Aldermanic Communication, which was read aloud by Alderman At-Large Stephanie Hirsch at the latest regular meeting of the Board, is a follows:

“Laura Levis died of a catastrophic asthma attack, just steps from the Somerville Hospital and one of Somerville’s Fire Stations. All of us around this horseshoe – and many of you in the audience and at home – have read the article her husband, Peter DeMarco, wrote about Laura that appeared in the Globe this past week.

Laura was a 34-year-old journalist living in Somerville. She had just received a promotion in her job at the Harvard Gazette. Peter describes her as funny, confident, and extremely smart. She loved to travel and was an amazing athlete with incredible physical (and mental) strength.

On that day in September, Laura walked to the Somerville Hospital Emergency room very early in the morning, because she knew she was experiencing an asthma attack. She found the Emergency Room doors that she went to were locked with no apparent way to get in. She called 911 and was connected to the State Police call center. As 911 operators tried to determine where she was outside the hospital and direct assistance, Laura lost consciousness. Help was on the way, but as Peter describes, due to gaps in geo-locating technology for 911 calls from cell phones, first responders did not know exactly where to look for Laura and initially did not find her. As described by Peter, by the time the first responders found Laura, she had gone without oxygen for so long that she did not recover brain activity once she received emergency treatment.

Maybe even more so because it seems like it was so preventable, this story is absolutely heart-breaking. The people who loved Laura replay what happened over and over. As Peter points out in his article, any one of many small differences in system design (or chance) would have meant a completely different outcome. We are grateful to Peter for telling this story. In his grief, he has looked for remedies so that others may not experience this overwhelming loss.

Peter DeMarco, whose wife Laura Levis died after suffering a fatal asthma attack, addressed the Somerville Board of Aldermen at their latest regular meeting last week.

We as a community – and we as a country – will need to take Peter’s advice and figure out how to improve our incredibly complicated and broken health care systems, where there are ANY emergency rooms that are considered the wrong place to go to receive life-saving care.

At a community care network, like Cambridge Health Alliance, we know that the vast majority of providers and staff are there because they have a strong sense of mission. (Here’s just one story about mission… My family are all Cambridge Health Alliance patients. Once, when I was with my then four-year-old son Joey at the Cambridge Hospital Emergency room, I could hear a family behind the curtain next to us. The nurse or doctor, speaking through a phone-based interpreter, talked to a toddler’s mom who had just come from El Salvador. The clinician had no access to the child’s medical records, so they were trying to figure out what treatment to give the little girl.) We know that the Cambridge Health Alliance is the first line of defense for many for the management of both acute and chronic conditions (maybe, ironically) like asthma. We need to fix systems and funding to help those providers carry out their mission for everyone, including patients who have no other options. Note that today’s Globe reports that the Cambridge Health Alliance, on behalf of Somerville Hospital, issued a statement apologizing for not meeting their own standards for transparency and accountability.

As with CHA clinicians and staff, we know that our first responders, like E911, Fire Alarm, Cataldo, Somerville Police, and Somerville Fire handle very confusing, life-and-death, situations often. (This is especially true with the recent increase in opioid overdoses, where the minutes required for administration of Narcan mean the difference between life and death.) First responders are haunted by a situation like this – the very worst kind of missed opportunity. Also, while this example is so pointed, it’s also a reminder that there are missed opportunities and lives lost due to system failures in other key government systems, like education and criminal justice.

Peter’s telling of Laura’s story is a call to all of us who are in positions of policy making at all levels to dedicate and re-dedicate ourselves to improving systems – even the sometimes dry and complex ones like health care and GPS technology – because they matter in the most profound ways. We want to express appreciation to Peter for his willingness to share this most personal story to make our community and ones like it better. And most of all, we want to honor Laura. She made a profound mark on the people around her, and leaves behind so much grief for all the missed opportunities in her future.

Last month, we shared a moment of silence for the loss of ten-year-old Jahmai Furtado-Cooper. Jahmai also died of an asthma attack just a month after Laura died and just a short distance away. We want their lives lived and their lives lost to matter. We want to pursue solutions with the passion that these two young people lived their lives – as a way to honor the unimaginable loss of lives ended far too soon.”

Following the reading of the Aldermanic Communication, Peter DeMarco addressed the Board, expressing his gratitude for its shedding light on the issue of competent emergency medical response.

In part, DeMarco said, ” Laura and I loved living in Somerville together. It was our home for almost all of our years here. I proposed to her in the backyard of our Davis Square apartment. When it came time to honor her memory we held her service at the Somerville Theatre.”

DeMarco emphasized that he did not write the Globe story to be vengeful, but rather to make a difference.

The Aldermanic Communication was approved unanimously, and will hopefully make a difference.

 

Update:  According The Boston Globe, the hospital has apologized and admitted to mulitple mistakes yesterday.   https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2018/11/13/somber-meeting-hospital-officials-apologize-husband-woman-who-suffered-fatal-asthma-attack/EgzAXMq4wG7m1E1U6A8PlK/story.html

 

5 Responses to “City expresses intent to improve emergency medical response”

  1. #why? says:

    This was indeed a sad story, and totally preventable. But in my opinion, based on the article and my experiences, the fault lies with Somerville Hospital/Cambridge Health Alliance. Yes, there were problems with her 911 call, and all of her information was not relayed correctly to first responders. However, CHA had no staff at the ER desk (visible from the bench where Laura sat), locked ER doors, no staff at the security booth, no signage indicating where to enter the ER, a staff member who, when asked to look for the patient, made a cursory attempt then said no one was there, when Mr. DeMarco was called, it was after the night staff (who could have given him information) had left, Mr. DeMarco thought Laura had collapsed before arriving at the hospital and the hospital did nothing to correct that. He only learned of the circumstances that occurred from a police officer’s report. I have seen firsthand CHA’s lack of compassion for patients. Why does the city still subsidize them and give them a voice in health matters? That is the question that needs to be answered.

  2. LindaS says:

    It’s a total disgrace that we are a city that is supposed to be so “progressive,” with all the focus on bringing people in here and gentrification, yet we don’t have a fully-working hospital.

    Somerville needs to have a fully operating hospital to deal with the number of people that live here, and have more than “adequate” services. It is ridiculous to think that what we currently have is enough to handle the amount of people that will need its services on a daily basis.

    Our Mayor needs to stop taking money from developers and building more apartments and condos we don’t need, and instead put funding into turning Somerville Hospital back into a fully-fledged medical service.

    My late mother had to be taken to the emergency room in 2008, and wound up needing to be transported to Cambridge Hospital for surgery. That should not have been necessary. Somerville has the bare minimum needed, and there simply is no excuse for that.

    We actually had two hospitals once, Central Hospital was one of them, but it was closed down many years ago. I had my tonsils out there when I was 11 years old. I can understand maybe only needing one full hospital in a city, but none?

    Cambridge Hospital has to deal with two cities’ worth of patients, and if those patients are coming from Somerville, that means extra time needed to transport those people, which endangers those lives even more. Add to that the need for extra staffing to handle the extra patients. Good luck with that. My mother’s care left much to be desired, but that’s another story.

    We need Somerville Hospital to be fully operational, not just a glorified Urgent Care Center. Don’t bring more people here if we’re not going to be able to handle medical emergencies for them. Nobody else should have to die as a result of inadequate service before something gets done.

  3. Tom says:

    The Aldermen once again are wasting our time and money discussing CHA. They should have just closed the hospital entirely after closing the detox, the mental health unit, and all hospital units. Just to save a little $$$. And the city had nothing to say about it. What’s the point in having an ER? Most true emergencies and you’ll have to pay ambulance costs to be transported elsewhere for any sort of treatment. Waste of time.

  4. Old Tazpayer says:

    Having taken my father there a couple of times I stopped going and headed straight to Mount Auburn by car. Not that they are the best either but the care in Somerville was just that bad. Each time we had to transfer him anyway as they did not have the ability to treat him. I don;t know why it is even open if they can;t treat people.

  5. Steve Keenan says:

    This is so sad. My thoughts and prayers go out to Mr. DeMarco.

    If you are in need of help in a situation like this you can pull a fire box to activate an alarm. A response from the fire department will come to the location of the fire alarm box that you pull. After you activate the fire alarm box STAY THERE UNTIL THE FIRE DEPARTMENT ARRIVES!